Overview of anonymous submission tools: differences between SecureDrop, GlobaLeaks, and OnionShare
There are several kinds of tools for anonymously passing information and documents.
Names that often appear are SecureDrop, GlobaLeaks, and OnionShare.
These are sometimes discussed as if they have similar purposes, but they are not the same thing. Some are operated by news organizations as continuing submission channels, some are suited to temporary file sharing, and some are used for internal reporting or organizational reporting intake.
Before choosing a tool, organize "who receives what, from whom, and how."
Positioning of the main tools
First, separate the broad role of each one.
Tool
Main use
Reason to introduce it
SecureDrop
A mechanism for news organizations and others to receive anonymous submissions
You can learn intake operation based on source protection
GlobaLeaks
A foundation for organizations to create reporting and submission channels
You can learn continuing report intake and handler management
OnionShare
Temporary file sharing and receiving using
You can learn small-scale transfer that avoids real-name cloud services
SecureDrop is a foundation for news organizations and organizations to receive anonymous submissions. Because the receiving-side operation needs to be designed around source protection, it is important in journalism and high-risk submission contexts. URL : https://securedrop.org/
GlobaLeaks is an open source foundation for organizations to operate anonymous reporting and submission channels. It becomes a candidate when creating continuing intake flows, such as internal reporting, public-interest whistleblowing, and channels for NGOs or public institutions. URL : https://globaleaks.org/
OnionShare is a tool suited to temporary file sharing and receiving using Tor. It becomes an option when you want to pass files on a small scale with limited recipients without using a real-name cloud service. URL : https://onionshare.org/
All of them relate to anonymity and safer transfer.
However, their operational assumptions are different.
SecureDrop
SecureDrop is a mechanism for news organizations, NGOs, and others to receive anonymous submissions.
The submitter accesses it with Tor Browser and sends documents or messages. The receiving side prepares a dedicated operational structure and checks the submissions.
Item
Content
Suited use
Submission channel for news organizations
Strength
Designed with source protection as an assumption
Caution
Requires a receiving-side operational structure
Remaining issues
Document metadata, inference from contents, publication judgment
SecureDrop is covered in detail in another article.
GlobaLeaks
GlobaLeaks is an open source foundation for creating internal reporting and submission channels.
It is used not only in journalism, but also in NGO, corporate, public-institution, audit, and compliance contexts. It is a mechanism designed around operations such as people submitting reports, receiving handlers, and case management.
Makes it easier to manage reporting flows and receiving handlers
Caution
The operator's policy and reliability are important
Remaining issues
Receiving-side logs, document management, explanations to people submitting reports
Using GlobaLeaks does not automatically make something safe.
Which organization operates it, what it records, and who can access it are important.
OnionShare
OnionShare is a tool for file sharing and receiving using Tor.
It is relatively easy for individuals to use and is suited to temporary transfer. Rather than a permanent channel like SecureDrop or GlobaLeaks, it is suited to sharing with limited recipients.
Item
Content
Suited use
Temporary file sharing, receiving, individual transfer
Strength
Easier to share without a real-name cloud account
Caution
Requires a path for passing the onion address
Remaining issues
File metadata, device safety, recipient handling
OnionShare is covered in detail in another article.
Which one to choose
When choosing a tool, choose by use, not by name recognition.
Situation
Candidate
Reason
A news organization creates an anonymous submission channel
SecureDrop
Mechanism conscious of source protection
An organization operates report intake
GlobaLeaks
Suited to reporting flows and handler management
Temporarily sharing a file individually
OnionShare
Easier to pass without placing it in the cloud
Receiving high-risk whistleblowing
SecureDrop or a specialized channel
The receiving-side structure is important
With any tool, file metadata, contact paths, and inference from publication or article content remain.
Tools protect the entrance, but they do not automatically protect the whole operation.
Official information to check before choosing
For anonymous submission tools, it is important not to judge from old introductory articles alone. Features, recommended configurations, cautions, and operational assumptions can change.
How to use file sharing, receiving, and publishing features
Do not judge safety by the tool name alone. Check who operates it, which version it uses, and what explanations it provides.
Users and operators need to look at different places
Submitters check their own devices, networks, documents, and behavior after sending. Operators check the receiving environment, access permissions, storage location, reply method, and source protection at publication.
Position
What to look at
Submitter
Device, connection path, document metadata, inference from content
Check the operating entity, not only the tool name
Anonymous submission does not work through the sending side alone or the receiving side alone. Safety improves only when both sides' operations are aligned.
Questions before choosing a tool
Before deciding a specific tool name, check the following questions.
Question
Reason
Who does the submitter need to be protected from?
Decide the threat model
Does metadata remain in the documents?
Prevent leakage outside the entrance
Who on the receiving side will see it?
Check permission management and responsibility
How will replies be handled?
Reduce traces from continuing contact
Can the source be inferred at publication?
Look at the risk from turning it into an article or report
Choose the tool after answering these questions. If you introduce only the tool while unable to answer the questions, you will mistake what needs protection.
In anonymous submission, the entrance, documents, contact, storage, and post-publication effects form one flow.
Summary
SecureDrop, GlobaLeaks, and OnionShare are tools used for anonymous submissions and file transfer.
SecureDrop is suited to anonymous submission channels for news organizations and similar recipients.
GlobaLeaks is suited to report intake and organizational submission flows.
OnionShare is suited to temporary file sharing and receiving using Tor.
What matters is operation, not the tool name.
Check who operates it, what is recorded, who can access it, and how received documents are handled.
Related tools
Anonymous communication
Tor Project
An external resource related to this article. Open it only when it fits your situation and threat model.
Why it is listed: It can help with the article topic, but it is outside Anonymity Sense and should be checked before use.