Correlation Risk When Posting Across Multiple Sites
Anonymous activity may involve using multiple sites and services.
Social networks, bulletin boards, blogs, video sites, Q&A sites, chat, file sharing, newsletters.
Separating places may look safe. However, if you use the same name, same image, same text, same posting time, same links, or same topics, accounts on separate sites become connected.
This article organizes what kinds of correlation arise when posting across multiple sites and what to check before posting.
Why You Can Look Like the Same Person Across Multiple Sites
Even when sites are different, user habits remain.
If naming patterns, profile text, icons, topics, posting times, writing style, links, images, and follow targets are similar, they create a sense of being the same person.
Shared item
Reason it connects
Point to watch
Username
Appears side by side in search
Do not reuse it
Profile image
Found through image search
Do not use the same material
Profile text
Background and phrasing overlap
Separate it from the real-name side too
Post content
Same topics or personal experiences
Watch for cross-posting
Posting time
Looks like the same operator
Avoid simultaneous posting
Links
Same path or destination
Also look at URL parameters
A different service does not necessarily mean a different person.
Think on the assumption that people will search across multiple sites.
Difference From Cross-Posting
Cross-posting means posting the same content in multiple places.
Multi-site correlation is a broader problem than that. Even when the text is not the same, accounts connect through how they are created and operated.
Item
Cross-posting
Multi-site correlation
Center
Same post content
Similarity of the whole account
Clues
Body text, title, image
Name, image, writing style, time, interactions
Countermeasure
Do not reuse post content
Separate roles by site
Do not assume you are safe just because you are not pasting the same text.
If the design of the whole account is similar, it can be correlated.
Decide the Role of Each Site
If you use multiple sites, decide the role of each one.
When consultation, publishing, information gathering, contact, and file sharing are mixed, the purpose expands too much and correlation increases.
Use
Reason to separate
Point to watch
Information gathering
Separate it from posting
Do not log in with a real name
Anonymous posting
Manage what you publish
Do not reuse the same writing style
Contact
Relationships with the other party remain
Separate contact methods and accounts
File sharing
Owner information is visible
Watch cloud history
If you do everything under one anonymous name, the profile of that person becomes more detailed.
Separate by use when necessary.
Internal Service Information and External Search
For multi-site correlation, separate information visible from outside from information that remains inside the service.
Even if outside readers cannot see it, service operators may retain email addresses, phone numbers, IP addresses, login times, and device information.
Viewer
Visible information
Point to watch
General readers
Posts, profiles, images
Look at correlation in public information
Search engines
Public pages, names, images
Multiple sites line up
Service operators
Registration information, logs, IP
Remains as internal information
People who know you
Writing style, interests, images
Human memory is also a clue
For anonymity, do not think "it is safe because it is not visible outside."
Separate who is looking and from what position.
Checks Before Posting
Before posting to multiple sites, check the following.
Whether you are using the same username
Whether you are using the same image or profile text
Whether you are pasting the same text or title
Whether you are posting at the same time or in the same time slot
Whether you are using the same URL or sharing link
Whether topics overlap with the real-name side or past accounts
Whether roles for each site are mixed
The more sites you use, the more information you have to manage.
Rather than expanding unnecessarily, narrowing activity to the places you need may be safer.
The Same Links and File Sharing Also Become Correlation
If you share the same link or same file across multiple sites, the posts connect even if the content is different.
If the same shortened URL, same cloud sharing link, same PDF, same image, or same file name appears on multiple sites, it looks like they are being used by the same operator.
Shared item
What happens
Point to watch
Same sharing link
Looks like the same distribution source
Check separately by use
Same PDF
Metadata or content matches
Separate publication files
Same image
Connects through image search
Do not reuse materials
Same shortened URL
Click analytics or paths overlap
Use shortened URLs carefully
Same file name
Case or person profile is visible
Change to a publication name
For multi-site correlation, look not only at text but also at shared objects.
Readers Differ by Site
Even with the same post, readers differ by site.
Information that is not understandable on a general social network may become meaningful in a specialist bulletin board, local community, or place where school or workplace contacts are present.
Posting destination
Information readers easily notice
Point to watch
General social network
Topic, image, time
Spreads widely
Specialist bulletin board
Technical terms, job type
Affiliation or experience is visible
Local community
Shops, stations, events
Routine places are visible
Hobby community
Old handles, images
Connects with past accounts
The more sites you post to, the more different kinds of readers see it.
For anonymity, think for each posting destination about "who would find this meaningful if they read it."
Do Not Expand if You Cannot Manage It
Operating across multiple sites increases the information you have to manage.
You need to look at logins, posting times, replies, images, links, profiles, and deletion responses for each site. If you expand to more sites than you can manage, somewhere the real-name side and past information will mix.
When anonymity is needed, check whether adding a posting destination is really necessary before you do it.
There are situations where you should prioritize not increasing correlation over spreading widely.
If you use multiple sites, also decide what you will not do on each site.
For example, create boundaries such as not posting from an information-gathering account, not following real-name contacts from a posting account, and not having conversations from a file-sharing account.
If you start using sites without deciding boundaries, information gathers in the convenient place and eventually forms one person profile.
When anonymity is needed, prioritize separation over convenience.
Also, deletion handling becomes distributed in multi-site operation.
If you cannot manage where and what you posted, old information can remain. When anonymity is needed, manage a list of posting destinations as a private memo that does not mix with cloud sync or the real-name environment, and review it regularly.
Summary
When you post to multiple sites, accounts can connect even if the sites are different.
Usernames, icons, profile text, writing style, topics, posting times, links, and follow relationships become material for correlation.
Even if you avoid cross-posting, if the design of the whole account is similar, it looks like the same person.
When using multiple sites, it is important to decide each site's role and not mix names, images, content, time, contact methods, and file sharing.
Related articles
Accounts and operation
Correlation Risk When Posting Across Multiple Sites
Using the same names, images, links, files, timing, and topics across sites can connect separate anonymous accounts.